- 1 OVDP Opt-Out & Streamlined are NOT the Same
- 2 Opt-Out is NOT Always the Best Choice
- 3 Do Other People Wish For Your Downfall?
- 4 The Benefits of the IRS Streamlined Program
- 5 Opting-Out vs. Streamlined
- 6 Our Advice – Vet Out Your OVDP Lawyer
- 7 You Can Always Change Attorneys
- 8 Golding & Golding, A PLC
- 9 We Take OVDP Representation Very Seriously
Differences Between OVDP Opt-Out & IRS Streamlined Offshore Program
Going “Streamlined” (IRS Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures) in order to bring your foreign/offshore accounts, investments, assets, etc. into compliance is NOT the same as going OVDP, and then opting-out.
OVDP Opt-Out & Streamlined are NOT the Same
There are appears to be some mass confusion as a result of inexperienced law firms telling potential clients that the two methods are the same.
In one recent scenario, we spoke with a client who told us the only reason he entered OVDP (he was completely non-willful and would have preferred the Streamlined Program) was because his prior attorney told him he should enter OVDP and then opt-out.
That way, he could avoid criminal liability and receive the same the 5% penalty. This advice is dangerous, because what the attorney failed to warn him of, is that the IRS could issue substantially higher penalties than the 5%. In addition, the client was not informed that the IRS would have the opportunity to audit his underlying multi-million dollar LLC businesses for upwards of 8 years. If he had known this, he would have 100% opted for the Streamlined Program.
Opt-Out is NOT Always the Best Choice
Sometimes, opting-out is a great idea. Depending on a person’s specific facts and circumstances, coupled by the person’s risk management level, potential penalties — and related issues which could reduce the penalty without an opt-out — such as making a mark-to-market election or qualifying for FAQ 55 removal of a portion of a penalty — the Opt-Out may work well.
Other times, it is not a great idea. For example, if a person has a somewhat shady US business and possibly may not completely be on the up and up in the first place – agreeing to open yourself up for an eight year audit is not necessarily the best strategy.
Do Other People Wish For Your Downfall?
When a person has made statements to other individuals such as ex-spouses, ex-business partners, or CPAs in which it will become clear to the IRS agent that the individual is willful – it is also not worth it to try to gamble a reduced penalty. Why? Because you really do not know how far into the investigation the IRS agent is going to want to push, and whether the audit is really a reverse Eggshell Audit in which the Agent is just waiting for you to trip up.
Moreover, who is the agent auditing you? Is it a new agent, or an experienced agent who knows all the secret “hiding places.” Is it someone gunning for promotion, or someone with one foot out the door towards retirement. In other words, opting out requires a complex analysis individualized to each persons set of facts and circumstances.
The Benefits of the IRS Streamlined Program
Under the streamlined program, a person can sidestep or circumvent traditional OVDP, and submit directly to the streamlined program instead. By doing so, they only have to amend three years of tax returns instead of eight, and submit six years of FBAR (FinCEN 114) instead of eight.
Moreover, the penalties are reduced and even wave depending on whether a person qualifies as a foreign resident.
The single most important aspect of a streamlined disclosure is to meet the definition of non-willful. As we have mentioned before, there is no concrete definition of the term non-willful, but common sense dictates the analysis. In other words, if you truly had no idea that you had a reporting requirement, and did not have a tax professional ask you, or educate you about foreign account reporting before filing your prior returns, there is a good chance you will qualify as non-willful.
It does not matter how much money you have (usually) and it does not matter how much income you have one report (again, usually). We preface this, because as shown in a recent case involving FBARs and Penalties the more money you have and depending on your level of business acumen, the more chance the IRS will expect that you retain an experienced tax professional to prepare your taxes.
But, even in that case the court held that the individual was not willful (even though the near max penalties under the non-willfulness aspect of the statute were issued).
Opting-Out vs. Streamlined
In all reality, these should not be to competing decisions. The reason why is because opting out may sound better in the brochure. Once you and and Experienced Offshore Voluntary Disclosure Program Lawyer have reviewed your information in detail, you may come to the sobering realization that even though you are non-willful, and opt out is too risky (based on other issues).
Therefore, by having entered OVDP, you are now stuck in OVDP. This seems to be one important concept which is missed by many beginner and inexperienced “international tax lawyers.” After a person has submitted beyond the preclearance letter, they do not have the opportunity to back out of OVDP.
Thus, if you get cold feet about opting out, you cannot now switch to the streamlined program, no matter how unfair it is.
On one occasion, prior counsel’s actions were so egregious, that the IRS Agent we were working with after taking over the case, was actually batting on behalf of the taxpayer. We laid out the facts in detail, and she actually pushed to have the case transferred to the streamlined program – but unfortunately IRS Trial Counsel explained that it is a precedent they are not willing to set, and therefore the cases moving towards opt-out. In this particular case, the facts could not have been anymore in favor of our client, but the IRS just will not budge – once you are in, you are in. That is just one of more than a dozen examples of current cases we’re trying to resolve as a result of bad lawyering.
Hopefully this will change in the future, so that Taxpayers are not held accountable for bad lawyering.
Our Advice – Vet Out Your OVDP Lawyer
Make sure you speak with the attorney who will be handling your case. As you can see from the more experienced OVDP and streamlined disclosure lawyers, we all have advanced degrees with Masters in Tax Law (LL.M.) and we all have either the EA (Enrolled Agent) or CPA (Certified Public Accountant) designation.
Make sure you discuss in detail how the case is going to be handled with the attorney. Make sure you have an opportunity to speak directly with the CPA or EA (if it is not the attorney being duly licensed), and ask what happens if you do not agree with the position taken by the CPA or EA, or do not like the Accountant’s work product? Are there extra fees?
It is important that you vet out the experience of both the tax attorney and the tax professional (CPA/EA/Accountant) – if they are using one – so that you have a confidence level regarding your entire submission.
We have been finding lately that “more senior attorneys” who do not have significant offshore disclosure experience are trying to jump into the Offshore Disclosure had first based on experience they have in other areas of law only to give absolutely terrible advice to clients. They then try to cut costs by referring the Accounting/CPA work to the least expensive person they can find, to dismal results.
Therefore, be sure to ask the attorneys how many cases they’ve handled in the last year, two years or five years? You should ask them difficult questions regarding your specific case so that you have an understanding that they understand your case and how to proceed. It is not the time to be shy.
In reality, if your attorney is not also handling the tax portion of the submission, then you will most likely have little to no say in choosing the tax preparer, communicating with the tax preparer, or disagreeing with the tax preparer.
You Can Always Change Attorneys
This is another very important fact to keep in mind. If you have lost confidence in your attorney, you should consider seeking out other counsel the best assist you. You should interview multiple Attorneys until you find the one that fits you best.
Golding & Golding, A PLC
At Golding & Golding, we have successfully handled numerous OVDP (Offshore Voluntary Disclosure Program) and IRS Streamlined Program applications for individuals and businesses around the globe with outstanding unreported foreign accounts ranging from $50,000.00 to nearly $40,000,000.00 in a single disclosure.
In order to assist you to better understand the distinction between the two different IRS offshore/foreign account disclosure programs, we are providing the following summary for your reference.
We Take OVDP Representation Very Seriously
The main takeaway from this article is that you understand the risks and pitfalls of entering either over OVDP or the Streamlined Offshore Disclosure Program unprepared.
We are passionate about representing individuals in offshore voluntary disclosure matters, and feel horrible when a client calls us after having hired an inexperienced Attorney or CPA who either did a sloppy job, charged them more money than they agreed upon, and/or is overall not providing the level of representation a person deserves.
We Can Help You!
Sean holds a Master's in Tax Law from one of the top Tax LL.M. programs in the country at the University of Denver, and has also earned the prestigious Enrolled Agent credential. Mr. Golding is also a Board Certified Tax Law Specialist Attorney (A designation earned by Less than 1% of Attorneys nationwide.)